The Yahoo Faux-Stream Fiasco: A Lesson in AdTech Shenanigans
Welcome to the wild world of advertising online, where the lines between "in-stream" and "outstream" are as clear as mud, and Yahoo's recent debacle has everyone buzzing. Our friend Erez Levin posed an intriguing question: Is Yahoo playing fast and loose with its video ad placements? Let's dive into the fracas and see if we can separate fact from fiction. The saga began back in August 2022 when the Interactive Advertising Bureau (IAB) dropped new video guidelines that redefined "in-stream" placements to require sound-on. This wasn't just a minor tweak; it was a significant shift in how video ads would be categorized and, ultimately, billed. Fast forward to April 2023, the IAB released an updated spec with even clearer definitions, presumably to close any loopholes that sneaky SSPs (Supply Side Platforms) might exploit. By the summer of 2023, The Trade Desk (TTD), a major player in the DSP (Demand Side Platform) world, started telling SSPs to get their act together and comply with the new spec. Fast forward to April 2024, and Google Ad Manager (GAM) was nudging publishers to start playing by the rules. Then came June 2024, the climax of our tale, when TTD called out Yahoo for non-compliance and threatened to cut them off if they didn't shape up. The heart of the issue?
Misdeclaring video ads as "in-stream" when they should be "outstream." Buyers were shelling out more than three times the CPM (cost per thousand impressions) for these misdeclared ads, with over a billion dollars reportedly spent on these overvalued formats. The financial implications are staggering, but let's not just point fingers at Yahoo without a deeper dive into the details. The Battle for
Transparency Erez Levin, always the straight shooter, brings up a crucial point: the responsibility lies not just with Yahoo but with the entire ecosystem. SSPs have been known to exaggerate the value of ad impressions, and marketers, all too eager to chase inflated metrics, often go along for the ride with only a flimsy process of quality control. David Kohl, Co-Founder & CEO of Symitri, doesn't mince words either. He
sees this as a symptom of a broader issue—open programmatic advertising being a dumpster fire. His perspective is shaped by years of trying to carve out a premium, trustworthy slice of the web for advertisers who value quality over quantity. Kohl's frustration is palpable as he laments how one bad actor can taint the entire industry, causing a devaluation of inventory across the board, even from honest suppliers. The
Industry’s Accountability Levin and Kohl both agree that this is a systemic problem, but Levin takes it a step further. For him, cracking down on faux-stream misrepresentation isn’t just a noble endeavor; it’s absolutely essential. Levin envisions a future where the ad industry
isn’t just a wild west of inflated metrics and dodgy practices. It’s about more than just pointing out the bad apples; it’s about reshaping the entire orchard. By tackling this high volume of overvalued and misdeclared inventory head-on, Levin believes we can force the market to finally grapple with genuine supply constraints. This means moving away from those sexy, yet utterly useless, vanity metrics that everyone loves to flaunt at industry conferences but do nothing for real value. It's about
creating a landscape where every ad dollar is spent wisely, transparently, and on inventory that actually delivers what it promises. Levin's perspective isn’t just about slapping the wrists of the wrongdoers; it's about catalyzing a fundamental shift in how the ad tech world operates. He argues that the industry has been hiding behind a smokescreen of inflated CPMs and dubious metrics for far too long. By exposing and eliminating faux-stream misrepresentation,
we’re not just cleaning up a single mess—we're compelling the entire industry to operate with honesty and transparency. This isn’t just a slap on the wrist; it's a call to arms for all marketers, publishers, and tech vendors to step up their game. In Levin's vision, it's high time the market stopped treating ad impressions like a game of monopoly money and started dealing with real, tangible value. Enter Eric Tilbury, another sharp mind with a clear stance on this
issue. Tilbury underscores the magnitude of the misrepresentation problem with the precision of a surgeon. Misdeclared video placements, he explains, do more than just inflate numbers—they fundamentally rob buyers of their power. When buyers can't accurately control where their ads run, select the right creatives, or price them appropriately, the whole system falls apart. It's not just about the financial loss; it's about the erosion of trust and the spread of opacity in an already murky
marketplace. Tilbury highlights how this misdeclaration fraud throws a wrench into the very machinery of programmatic advertising. Advertisers are left in the dark, making decisions based on faulty data and inflated promises. The result? A marketplace where trust is a scarce commodity, and transparency is more of a buzzword than a reality. This isn’t just bad for business; it’s bad for everyone involved. Tilbury’s point is crystal clear: to fix the system, we need
to root out these deceptive practices and restore control to the buyers. Only then can we build a marketplace based on genuine value and trust, not on the shifting sands of misdeclared metrics and inflated CPMs. The Road Ahead So, where do we go from here? Yahoo, confident in their labeling practices, needs to come forward and publicly detail
their rationale. Show the world what your placements look like and let the industry reach a consensus on whether they meet the new standards. Until then, skepticism will reign supreme. The broader lesson here isn't just about Yahoo or any single company. It's about the integrity of the entire AdTech ecosystem. Marketers need to demand better, SSPs must commit to transparency, and everyone in between needs to prioritize real value over inflated metrics. Otherwise,
we're just slapping new labels on old problems and hoping no one notices. In the end, whether Yahoo cleans up its act or continues to play fast and loose, one thing is clear: the days of unchecked misrepresentation are numbered. The industry is watching, and the call for transparency and accountability is louder than ever. It's time to step up, show your cards, and prove that you're not just another player in the AdTech circus, but a champion for true value and
integrity.
|
THREE STORIES THAT YOU NEED TO KNOW in a format that isn't TL:DR summarized for the busy executive
Cue the ad industry's meltdown: the latest version of the American Privacy Rights Act
has them clutching their pearls, fearing a future where their beloved targeted ads are sent to the same graveyard as dial-up internet. The new bill flips the script by outright banning the tracking of consumers across sites and apps for ad purposes, ditching the previous opt-out compromise. In a dramatic letter, Privacy for America warns Congress that this legislative killjoy will suffocate innovation and cut off consumers from their favorite online indulgences. Expect a showdown on
Thursday as the House Energy and Commerce Committee tackles this privacy-versus-profits clash. Chipotle is throwing a social media fiesta, offering five lucky fans their coveted Celebrity Card—one free meal a day for a year—to anyone who can impress them on TikTok, Instagram, or X. Originally a LinkedIn gig, the contest quickly spilled over to other platforms due to overwhelming demand, underscoring
how social media now dictates celebrity status. With a nod to their Gen Z fans, Chipotle invites creative content using #CelebCardContest until July 3. This move not only boosts brand loyalty amid high food prices but also proves Chipotle’s knack for engaging marketing stunts that resonate with younger audiences. Macy's is diving into summer like a kid into a pool, with their "Summer's Greatest Hits" campaign. Featuring a fresh take on Bill Withers' "Lovely Day" by Amber Mark and produced by Ryan Tedder, Macy’s aims to make every summer moment a hit. This multi-channel blitz will light up your screens, from digital and social media to
TV and out-of-home displays, culminating in a grand performance during Macy’s 4th of July Fireworks on NBC. With new CMO Sharon Otterman steering the ship, this campaign is Macy’s splashy attempt to keep spirits high despite plans to shutter 150 stores. Let's hope this sunny celebration can weather the retail storm!
You're looking for an edge in your online marketing. ADOTAT.com is the answer. Our library of resources has been compiled by some of the world's top internet marketing experts, and it's constantly updated with new information, case studies, and
strategies. We want to help you succeed online - that's why we offer this information for free. It's our way of giving back to the community and helping people achieve their business goals.
Sign up now and gain access to our entire library of
resources!
Want to advertise? Contact pesach@adotat.com |
|
|
The most POWERFUL name in
CIPA AI class action defense and counseling
|
8 Billion and Counting? The Real Deal with X's Video View Numbers. Ladies and gentlemen, grab your popcorn, because X (formerly Twitter) is back with some eye-popping claims about its video content. They’re shouting from the rooftops that they’re
racking up 8 billion video views per day. Yep, you heard that right—8 billion, with a ‘B’. And just to spice things up, they’re flaunting a 35% increase year-over-year. But before you start planning a ticker-tape parade, let’s break down what’s really going on here. READ MORE
From ESPN to Clickbait: The Trade Desk’s Curated List of Digital Darlings. The Trade Desk, the darling of the demand-side platform (DSP) universe, has just unveiled its list of the top 100 premium publishers across the open internet. This list
spans TV, web, and audio publishers globally, and it's making waves in the ad tech community. But what's the real scoop behind this curated list of digital darlings? READ MORE
Dominick Miserandino, a name synonymous with digital strategy, is the guy you want on your side when navigating the ever-shifting sands of the internet. Since the 90s, he’s been a digital cowboy, riding the waves from dial-up days to the high-speed, AI-driven world
we live in now. Pesach Lattin got him to spill the beans on how he’s managed to stay relevant without losing his mind—or his audience. READ MORE
Taking Out the Trash: Welcome to the wild world of adtech, where the middlemen – those those highway robbers, money-grubbing gatekeepers, and digital parasite – have reigned supreme for years. They’ve siphoned ad revenue from
publishers and lined their own pockets with grand promises of digital marketing miracles. What did they actually deliver?
READ MORE
Hold onto your coffee, The Trade Desk just threw us a curveball by pivoting to become an advertising network. You heard right. The beloved DSP, which marketers used for buying digital ads, is now diving into the world of ad networks. Imagine your favorite bakery suddenly selling car parts—it’s that kind of switch. READ THE FULL STORY HERE
Enter the self-proclaimed adtech gurus, those walking, talking embodiments of the Dunning-Kruger effect, strutting around like peacocks in a pigeon coop. You’ve seen them on LinkedIn, Twitter, and every platform where their soapbox fits.
They preach their gospel of nonsense with the fervor of a televangelist, ready to save your marketing soul. These characters, barely old enough to grow a proper mustache or so ancient they’re still talking about “cell phones” and “the world wide web,” claim to have the “top 10 tips for better copywriting,” the “ultimate workflow hacks,” and a “foolproof” way to beat creative block. Spoiler alert: it’s all shtuyot.
|
|