U of Digital will help your teams get smarter in crucial areas like privacy / addressability, clean rooms, programmatic, connected TV, AI and more.

We helps teams at leading companies like Yahoo, TikTok, NBCU, Criteo get smarter about the industry so they can deliver better outcomes for their customers and grow their business.

How can U of Digital help you? 
Contact U of Digital to learn more. 

Twice the Bids, Twice the Trouble: A Programmatic Advertising Farce

A persistent and insidious issue lurks, often unnoticed by the everyday internet user yet acutely problematic for industry insiders: bid duplication. This issue, while not as visible as the flashy advancements in AI targeting or the revolutionary promises of blockchain for transparency, plays a pivotal role in the digital advertising ecosystem, subtly but significantly skewing the market dynamics. And we are talking about it again, for some reason -- almost a year after it was a "hot topic."

Bid duplication, for the uninitiated, is akin to a Kafkaesque scenario in the digital advertising world. Imagine a scenario where the same ad space, a digital asset in high demand, is offered multiple times in an auction setup. This is not a display of abundance or a testament to the richness of available inventory. Rather, it's a systemic flaw, a glitch in the matrix of programmatic advertising that distorts the market, creating an illusionary world where the same ad space is mirrored across multiple platforms, confusing buyers and muddying the waters of ad pricing.

At its core, the issue of bid duplication is not just an operational nuisance. It has profound implications for all parties in the digital advertising chain. Advertisers, seeking to place their ads in the most optimal spaces, are often misled by the apparent diversity of options, leading to inflated costs and a distorted perception of inventory availability. Publishers, on the other side, face the repercussions on their ad revenue and the integrity of their ad spaces. The inflated and duplicated ad space market opens up avenues for ad fraud, a persistent ghost in the machine of digital advertising.
To truly grasp the mechanism of bid duplication, one must first wade into the murky waters of the programmatic advertising ecosystem. At its core, this system involves publishers offering up digital ad spaces, or inventory, which are then purchased by advertisers through a complex network of intermediaries. These intermediaries include Supply Side Platforms (SSPs), which are services that allow publishers to manage their ad inventory and optimize their revenue. However, when a single ad space is controlled by multiple SSPs, the potential for bid duplication arises. Each SSP, eager to maximize the revenue for its share of the inventory, sends out its own bid requests to advertisers. As a result, the same ad space is inadvertently or deliberately offered up multiple times in the bidding process.

The process starts innocuously enough. A publisher's website with available ad space sends out a signal to multiple SSPs it partners with. These SSPs, acting as the publisher’s proxies in the digital ad marketplace, then broadcast bid requests for this ad space to various Demand Side Platforms (DSPs), where advertisers are connected. Ideally, this setup should increase competition and help the publisher secure the best price for their ad space. However, the lack of synchronization among SSPs means that multiple, identical bid requests for the same ad space flood into the market. To the DSPs and the advertisers they represent, it appears as if there is more inventory available than there actually is, creating an illusion of abundance.

This illusion is where the problem intensifies. Advertisers, operating under the assumption that they are bidding on distinct ad spaces, may end up competing against themselves. This competition drives up the price of the ad space, benefiting the SSPs and potentially the publishers, but at a significant cost to advertisers. They end up paying more for ad space than they should, based on a false perception of scarcity and competition. Moreover, this situation makes it challenging for advertisers to effectively strategize their ad placements, as they cannot accurately gauge the actual availability and value of the inventory.

The term 'yield optimization' is often bandied about to justify this practice. In theory, yield optimization is about maximizing the revenue generated from each ad space. However, in the context of bid duplication, it morphs into a strategy that prioritizes SSPs’ and publishers’ revenue over market transparency and fair pricing. The pursuit of higher bids under the guise of yield optimization ends up creating a market that is less about finding the true value of ad space and more about exploiting the structural inefficiencies of the programmatic advertising system.

This pursuit of higher bids, while seemingly beneficial to publishers and SSPs in the short term, has wider implications for the health of the digital advertising ecosystem. For advertisers, it erodes trust in the programmatic process and can lead to inflated advertising costs, which ultimately may be passed on to consumers. Furthermore, it creates an environment ripe for ad fraud, as the confusion and lack of transparency in bid requests can be exploited by malicious actors. In the long run, this could lead to a decrease in advertiser engagement with programmatic channels, reducing revenue for both publishers and SSPs – a classic example of short-term gains leading to long-term pains.

Recent controversies, such as the one involving Comcast’s Freewheel, have cast a glaring spotlight on these murky practices. Accusations of deliberately inflating bid requests to extract additional revenue from Demand Side Platforms (DSPs) have opened a can of worms, raising questions about ethics and transparency in the digital ad world. This revelation is akin to discovering a hidden hand in a game that's already complex and high-stakes.

Addressing bid duplication requires a deep dive into the intricacies of programmatic advertising. It's a world where ad spaces are traded in milliseconds, where algorithms make lightning-fast decisions, and where the line between optimization and manipulation can be perilously thin. The ecosystem is a web of SSPs, DSPs, ad exchanges, and a plethora of other intermediaries, each playing a role in the life cycle of an ad space. In this fast-paced environment, bid duplication is not just a bug; it's a feature for some, a strategy to inflate prices and create a false sense of competition.
Dive deeper into the murky waters of bid duplication, and you'll find that its impact isn't just about dollars and cents. It's a trust buster, a veritable sledgehammer to the fragile glass of advertiser and publisher confidence. When advertisers and publishers sign up for the programmatic ad circus, they're not just buying and selling digital real estate; they're entering into a tacit pact, built on the pillars of fairness, efficiency, and transparency. Bid duplication, with its hall-of-mirrors effect, distorts this pact. It turns the programmatic marketplace into a carnival game where the rules seem rigged and the prizes just out of reach. In this world, skepticism becomes the rational response, dimming the once-bright promise of programmatic advertising.

But wait, there's more! The reverberations of bid duplication resonate across the broader digital advertising landscape, touching on everything from ad fraud to user experience, and even brand safety. Let's talk about ad fraud first – the bogeyman of the digital ad world. Bid duplication creates fertile ground for fraudulent activities. It's like leaving your backdoor open in a neighborhood of opportunistic thieves. Fraudsters thrive in the chaos of duplicated bids, slipping through the cracks and siphoning off funds that should be driving real engagement. This not only drains advertiser wallets but also undermines the credibility of the entire programmatic system.

Then there's the impact on the unsuspecting victims at the end of this chain – the users. In the whirlwind of duplicated bids, advertisers often end up unwittingly bombarding users with the same ads over and over. It's like being stuck in a time loop of commercial breaks, where the same ad haunts you at every click. This relentless ad assault leads to what we call 'ad fatigue' – users becoming so numb to the barrage of ads that engagement plummets. And when engagement goes down the drain, so does the return on investment for advertisers, turning their marketing dreams into digital dust.

But wait, there's even more! Bid duplication, in its chaotic dance, can lead advertisers to unwittingly place their ads in unsavory digital neighborhoods. This misplacement isn't just a minor faux pas; it's akin to a reputable brand setting up shop in the digital equivalent of a seedy alleyway. The consequences? Damaged reputations, lost consumer trust, and a long road to redemption.

From a technical standpoint, tackling bid duplication is a Herculean task. It requires a harmonious symphony of technology solutions, industry standards, and cooperative efforts among all stakeholders. Technology solutions like advanced ad verification tools and improved algorithmic transparency can help identify and reduce duplication. Industry standards and best practices, agreed upon and adhered to by all players in the programmatic chain, can provide a framework for more ethical and transparent operations.

The future of programmatic advertising in the face of bid duplication is at a crossroads. On one path lies continued obfuscation and short-term gains for a few; on the other, a more transparent, efficient, and trustworthy ecosystem. The industry's collective actions in the coming years will determine which path is taken. 

As the digital advertising landscape continues to evolve, the hope is that the focus will shift from exploiting systemic loopholes to building a marketplace where quality and transparency are not just ideals but the foundational pillars of every transaction.

Pesach Lattin
Editor-in-Chief, ADOTAT

Please connect to my new linkedin profile just for this publication

Listen to the ADOTAT podcast on Spotify!

All the news you need today, 

in a format  that isn't TL:DR summarized  for the 

busy executive.

🤖🌐 Meta's CEO Mark Zuckerberg is all-in on AI, announcing big plans to mesh artificial intelligence with Meta's metaverse dreams. The goal? To develop general intelligence, open-source it, and spread the AI love so everyone gets a piece of the action. While AGI (automated general intelligence) is still more sci-fi than reality, Zuckerberg's stoked about its potential across Meta's app family. To power this ambitious vision, Meta's hoarding Nvidia's H100 GPUs like there's no tomorrow, eyeing a treasure trove of 600,000 by end of 2024. Plus, they're merging their AI brainiac teams, FAIR and GenAI, to speed things up. And get this: Meta's planning to let users create their own AI characters (hello, personal bots!) to roam their social apps. Topping it off, they're pouring $15 billion yearly into Reality Labs, betting AI will jazz up their hardware, including those slick Ray-Ban smart glasses. Zuckerberg's eyeing a future where AI bots and humans mingle in a high-tech global playground. 🕶️💡🌍

📍🔍 The FTC just put InMarket Media in a timeout for playing too fast and loose with location data. Turns out, they were not just tracking where you chill, but also selling the scoop on sensitive spots visits. No more of that, says the FTC, demanding explicit thumbs-up from consumers before any data grab. InMarket, caught creating a whopping 2,000 ad segments like "suburban moms" or "home-schooling parents," had to wave the white flag. So, next time you're near a pharmacy, maybe no more oddly specific ads for toothpaste! 🚫📱💬

🔥🌲 Solo Stove, known for its smokeless fire pits, tried to heat up sales with a Snoop Dogg twist, but ended up with more smoke than fire. The "smokesman" stunt, kicking off with Snoop's cryptic "giving up smoke" tease, initially lit up social media and earned media buzz. Despite the high hopes, this pricey celebrity move didn't spark the expected sales surge among outdoor enthusiasts. Now, Solo Brands, after a less-than-sizzling financial report and a CEO shuffle, is feeling the burn. Turns out, Snoop's cool factor might not mesh with campfire vibes, leaving Solo Stove to ponder if their marketing match was a bit too off-trail. 🌳🚫💰

🔍👚 Gap Inc., the fashion heavyweight, is shaking things up! They're rethinking their U.S. media agency strategy, even after dropping a cool $190 million on media last year. Omnicom’s PHD, the reigning champ, is gearing up to defend its title. Gap, with its crew of Old Navy, Banana Republic, Athleta, and the Gap brand itself, is on a mission for a brand makeover, aiming to boost both bucks and buzz. Despite hauling in $15.6 billion in 2022, they're bracing for a possible sales dip this year. It's all about staying sharp and relevant in the ever-changing fashion game. 💸📈🛍️

🎯📈 Retail's big leap! At the National Retail Federation's show, it's clear retail media is getting a major makeover, stepping into either its 2.0 or 3.0 era. Goodbye, old-school search and display ads; hello, in-store ad revolution! With giants like Walmart and 7-Eleven turning aisles into ad spaces and Instacart playing with AI-powered carts, it's all about blending the digital with the physical. The goal? To make shopping aisles the new prime-time TV. It's a mix of high tech and high touch, with a dash of "let's hope this works!" 🛒🤖💡

🎮🚗💨 Surprise in esports! BLAST, a Danish company, just scored big by partnering with Epic Games to run "Rocket League" esports, leaving industry insiders 🤯. This twist overtakes expectations of Saudi-Arabian-owned ESL/FACEIT clinching the deal. BLAST, already a whiz at "Fortnite" events, now gears up to turbocharge "Rocket League" with its event, sales, and marketing magic. While the deal's finer details are under wraps, it's a long-term play. For "Rocket League" fans and players, it's game on, no matter who's behind the joystick. 🏆🕹️🌍 (digiday)

🕺💡 TikTok's not just for dance moves anymore! Adobe's latest scoop shows a whopping 10% of Gen Z ditching Google for TikTok when they need answers. Millennials, Gen X, and even Baby Boomers are hopping on this trend too. Whether it's whipping up a new recipe, tuning into the latest tunes, DIY hacks, or fashion fixes, TikTok's the new 'Ask Jeeves'. And let's talk video tutorials - 62% of users are all in for these visual guides. Business owners, perk up your ears: video tutorials are outshining traditional search results. Plus, creative content, product reviews, and influencer chit-chat are big hits. If you're not on TikTok yet, you might be missing out on a goldmine of potential customers, especially if your biz is in one of those hot search categories! 🎥🔍

🍪🕵️‍♂️ GA4's like the cool new kid on the block, mixing up the old cookie jar with a dash of future tech! It's tracking users like a pro, doling out unique _ga cookies to every visitor like exclusive VIP passes. Want a sneak peek? Dive into the User explorer, where you'll find every digital footprint neatly lined up. But hey, it's not just about collecting data – GA4's playing nice with privacy rules, making sure everyone's data is as safe as a secret diary. So, whether you're a data geek or a privacy ninja, GA4's got something for everyone. 🚀📊💾

🇮🇹🍰 Chiara Ferragni, Italy's selfie queen and influencer extraordinaire, finds herself in a sticky situation sweeter than Christmas cake. Her partnership with Balocco for a charitable pandoro cake – priced at a hefty €9 – promised donations to a children's hospital but crumbled under scrutiny. Turns out, the hospital got a pre-campaign €50,000, while Ferragni pocketed over €1m. Italy's anti-trust body wasn't amused, slapping fines on both Ferragni and Balocco. Amid apologies and a pledge to donate €1m to the hospital, Ferragni's empire is wobbling, losing followers and big clients faster than a cake loses its icing. This tale's moral? Even influencers can't sugarcoat a half-baked charity scheme. 📉🤳✨

📉 Starting today, Meta's ad game is changing: they're dialing back on detailed ad targeting options. 🎯 The full list of axed categories is still under wraps, but health, race, and ethnicity are on the chopping block. 🚫 Details are scarce, but we're all ears for more info. 🤔 Ads using these soon-to-be-gone targeting options have until March 18 to run their course. ⏳ Then, it's update time! Why the big change? Meta's aiming for a more ethical, discrimination-free ad world, stepping away from super-specific targeting. 🌍🕊️ Their solution? Leaning into automated options like Meta Advantage+ audience, promising better ad performance. 🤖📈 This shift might just be the start of a bigger trend towards systematic display options in the ad industry. Stay tuned! 📻👀 #MetaShift #AdEvolution

🎬📉 VideoAmp, once buzzing with optimism, is now dialing down its energy levels. 2023 saw them as a top contender in alternative TV ad measurement, but the heat of market competition is causing some cracks. 🛠️ Last week, they bid farewell to 20% of their team and waved goodbye to their CEO, Ross McCray, with board member Peter Liguori stepping up as the interim boss. This layoff wave follows a 10% cut just five months earlier. 🐢 Behind the scenes, VideoAmp's alternative TV currency business isn't sprinting as fast as the headlines suggested. Mostly making dough from client campaigns, the company's finding it tough to stay afloat without this financial lifesaver. 💸 With cash burning fast and revenue projections trimmed, layoffs became inevitable, an insider spilled to AdExchanger.

Elf Cosmetics is blending beauty with mystery in their latest glam caper 🕵️‍♀️🎥. "Cosmetic Criminals," a 15-minute mockumentary, takes us on a wild ride through a true crime-style tale of a makeup thief and a house full of shady suspects 💄🔍. This isn't your average YouTube flick; it's hitting the big screens in AMC theaters, setting the stage for Paramount’s "Mean Girls" adaptation 🍿🎬. You can also stream this beauty whodunnit on Amazon Freevee – talk about making a dramatic entrance into the world of cosmetics and crime! 🤩🎉

Disney's streaming dreams are looking a bit like a roller coaster ride 🎢 in the world of direct-to-consumer (D2C) business. The Magic Kingdom's 2023 forecast? A not-so-magical $2.5 billion loss 💸, despite some pixie dust efforts to trim the deficits. MoffettNathanson Research points out that when Disney's D2C is stacked against Netflix's glittering past performance, with over $20 billion in revenue, Disney is still lagging in the trend race 🐢🚀. Flashback to 2019: Netflix was basking in a sunny $20.2 billion revenue with a cozy $2.6 billion positive cash flow, strutting a 13% profit margin 🌞💰. Meanwhile, Disney is playing catch-up with a projected negative 13% profit margin on $19.9 billion in revenue for 2023, though slightly up from last year's 19% margin dive 📉.

🎬 Netflix's ad-supported plan is booming with 23 million MAUs, a big jump from 15 million! 📈 Amy Reinhard, the ad chief, shares that 85% of these users are actively streaming for over 2 hours monthly. 🕑 Launched at $6.99/month in November 2022, this plan is a key strategy after Netflix faced subscriber drops in early 2022. 📉 By Q3, it's already 30% of new sign-ups in 12 countries, marking a turnaround for the streaming giant. 🌍 Netflix is focused on growing this user base while keeping content and ads engaging. 🎥👀 #NetflixAdsOnTheRise #StreamingStrategySucces

📱 Gen Z and News: Digiday+ uncovers Gen Z's (born 1997-2012) preference for social media over traditional news sources. 🌍 51% of younger Gen Z get news from social feeds and messaging, with Instagram and similar platforms being key. 📲 A Reuters study shows 39% of 18-24-year-olds use social media as their main news source. News orgs are adapting with platform-specific content. 💬 Christina Capatides of CBS News emphasizes the need for brand content to mimic creator content. TikTok is a major news source for 32% of U.S. adults under 30, says Pew Research. 📊 Lulu Chiang of ABC News highlights the trust Gen Z places in social platforms for news. (SOURCE)

🚫📱👎 "Just because you can, doesn't mean you should!" TikTok Ads, take note: Non-skippable ads might just be your downfall. Users crave control, with 73% more engaged when they can skip and 56% more likely to watch with that freedom. A MediaScience study reveals half the ad impact happens in the first 2 seconds. Forcing views? Not a click-winner. Test it, but listen to your data—it speaks volumes! 📊👥💡

🏈📈 The NFL's 2023 season scored big with a 7% hike in TV viewership and a slight uptick in stadium attendance, reaching 18.9 million. Every team was on fire, selling over 93% of tickets, a stark contrast to 2021's pandemic slump. Highlight teams: Detroit Lions, basking in their first division win in 30 years, and Washington Commanders, with a 10% jump in attendance under new leadership. Globally, the NFL's game plan includes Chicago Bears, Minnesota Vikings, Jacksonville Jaguars, and Carolina Panthers playing abroad in 2024. It's more than just touchdowns; it's a global sports blitz! 🌎🏟️🎟️
 

You're looking for an edge in your online marketing.
Interest: ADOTAT.com is the answer.

Our library of resources has been compiled by some of the world's top internet marketing experts, and it's constantly updated with new information, case studies, and strategies.

We want to help you succeed online - that's why we offer this information for free. It's our way of giving back to the community and helping people achieve their business goals.

 Sign up now and gain access to our entire library of resources!

Want to advertise? Contact pesach@lattin.us

The most POWERFUL 

name in 

TCPA
Privacy

CIPA

AI 

class action defense 

and 

counseling

Tech Titans on the Turf: The Trade Desk’s Offensive Against Google
In the high-stakes game of digital advertising, The Trade Desk and Google are like rival football teams, each with its own playbook, vying for the championship title in a league where the rules are constantly changing. The recent accusation by The Trade Desk’s CMO, Ian Colley, that Google has to "bribe companies" to test their Privacy Sandbox APIs, throws the equivalent of a bold, challenging flag on the field, signaling a heated contest ahead. READ MORE NOW

Survivor: Adtech Edition. Layoffs, AI, and the Quest for Relevance
The capricious world of online advertising: where the only constant is change, and the recent shifts are as dramatic as a telenovela finale. As 2023 waved goodbye, the industry stood tall, proud of its employment zenith. But as we all know, what goes up must come down.
READ MORE 

Nick Friese of Digiday, Lana McGilvray of Purpose Worldwide and speaker and author Ted Rubin Joined us for a discussion on work-home balance 

WATCH ON YOUTUBE NOW!

The Attention Alchemist: How Yan Liu is Redefining TV's Golden Metric
In the restless panorama of media and technology, where the flickering screens hold sway over the collective gaze, Yan Liu stands as a visionary sculptor of invisible data. As CEO and co-founder of TVision, Liu is not merely observing the tides of television viewership but actively reshaping the way brands, agencies, and TV media sellers comprehend the deep, often unseen currents of viewer attention. READ MORE OF THIS STORY

Welcome to 2024, the year that the AdTech industry decided to throw itself a surprise party, only to realize it had forgotten to invite stability. In this whirlwind of a year, we're witnessing a consolidation in the industry that's less like a well-orchestrated ballet and more like a flash mob in a bazaar. Picture this: a landscape where the rules are written in invisible ink, and the players are as unpredictable as a game of 3D chess in a wind tunnel. READ THIS COLUMN

FAST and Curious: The Free Ad-Supported TV Phenomenon Taking Over Streaming
Netflix’s dive into the ad-infested waters isn’t just a splash—it’s a cannonball that’s sent waves through the SVOD sea. In a landscape where “subscriber growth” was the chant, the major players are now humming a different tune: advertising tiers. This shift is more than just a fad.

The year 2023 in media was less a rollercoaster and more a rocket ride to the moon—without a clear landing strategy. WGA and SAG-AFTRA strikes turned studios into frantic chefs in a kitchen where half the ingredients are missing. This chaos was the backdrop to the intensifying streaming wars. READ MORE AND LEARN MORE

For a deeper understanding of digital identity in advertising, our round table discussion with industry experts is a must-watch. The panelists delve into the challenges marketers face in this evolving landscape, emphasizing the need for adaptability in response to regulatory changes and platform shifts. They highlight the importance of balancing precise advertising with user privacy and underscore the potential of contextual advertising and local/geo-targeting. Key topics include the role of first-party data, collaboration within walled gardens, AI's influence in privacy debates, and navigating user perceptions. The discussion also touches on the impact of government regulation and the criticality of industry education. This comprehensive conversation offers valuable insights for marketers navigating the post-cookie era and the future of identity in 2024.
WATCH NOW

Identity Icing: Shaping Marketing Identity in a Post-Cookie World
The marketing world is at a crossroads with the decline of third-party cookies. This once ubiquitous and economical tool, embraced by publishers, advertisers, and agencies alike, is now nearing its end. Triggered by a combination of heightened data protection regulations and consumer privacy concerns, this shift challenges the core practices of targeted advertising and inventory monetization. The question that now looms large is how brands and publishers can adapt to maintain effectiveness without these digital mainstays. Folks who have been baking cookies for all this time, suddenly are being told they need to make cake, and frankly, they were bad bakers to start with. READ MORE OF THIS STORY

2023’s AdTech Odyssey: Navigating the Six Trends That Illuminated the Digital Landscape
As we stand on the cusp of a pristine year, it is but second nature to pivot our collective gaze towards the all-encompassing tapestry that unfurled in 2023’s advertising technology (AdTech). Picture, if you will, a grand labyrinth bathed in the resplendent glow of digital luminescence—a labyrinth where the intricate choreography of innovation, strategy, and ethical enigmas entwined in a captivating dance. READ THE ARTICLE

YAHOO RISES FROM THE DIIGITAL ASHES
Silicon Valley giants and plucky startups alike vie for the spotlight in the adtech world but a familiar name is making an extraordinary comeback. Yahoo, the once-ubiquitous portal to the online universe, is scripting a revival that’s as unexpected as it is impressive. This resurgence is not just a tale of technological innovation; it’s a story of strategic reinvention, led by the launch of Yahoo Blueprint, an AI-powered suite that’s redefining the landscape of digital advertising. READ THE STORY AND LEARN MORE

Billion-Dollar Blindspots: The ANA Report’s Eye-Opening Revelations
In the complex world of digital advertising, the Association of National Advertisers (ANA) has released a groundbreaking report, shedding light on the often opaque and misunderstood intricacies of programmatic media buying. This detailed study, analyzing an impressive $123 million in advertising spend from notable brands such as State Farm, Mondelez, and Discover, spans the period from September 2022 to January 2023. It offers an unvarnished look at the realities of digital advertising, where the conventional wisdom about the relationship between the cost of media and its quality is turned on its head. READ MORE

Roblox Roulette: Why Some Brands Win, and Others Just Lose
A common misconception continues to lure brands into treacherous waters: the belief that mere presence guarantees relevance, and relevance, in turn, ensures resonance. This misguided notion has led many brands to venture into the captivating world of Roblox, a thriving digital universe, only to find themselves grappling with disappointment. The burning question arises: Why do so many brands stumble when trying to harmonize with the Roblox community? Let’s embark on a comprehensive exploration of the matter. READ MORE NOW

OOH LA LA: THE TRANSFORMATION OF OUTDOOR ADS FROM SIMPLE TO SMART
In the labyrinth of advertising history, Out-of-Home (OOH) advertising stands like an ancient monolith, etching its story into the very walls that house our everyday lives. From the first lease of a billboard in 1867, a time when the world was draped in the smoke of the industrial revolution, to the neon-drenched present, OOH advertising has not just survived; it has thrived, morphing with the ages, mirroring human ingenuity. 
READ MORE