The Right Way To Measure Media
THE PROBLEM WITH MEDIA MEASUREMENT “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted; the trouble is I don't know which half.” The quote, from retail magnate and marketing pioneer John Wanamaker, is over 100 years old. Despite digital media’s promise of accountability, many retailers still struggle with this attribution conundrum. The goal of understanding how marketing and advertising resources are consumed and determining the return on those efforts is necessary to optimizing the marketing mix. Attribution model after attribution model is developed, with endless amounts of
touch point data attempting to determine the magic ingredients that drove consumer behavior. Using the wrong models and approaches can lead to exactly the wrong conclusions, thereby being precisely wrong rather than vaguely right. Many are waiting for the perfect model. The situation seems to closely parallel Waiting for Godot, and for those who implore more rationality in media measurement, bringing a rope in the final scene echo as well! We’ve written this paper because we’ve witnessed first-hand the misleading results of ham-fisted and sometimes lazy models. At Undertone, we offer unique High Impact digital circulars, recipe ads, and more, all personalized through a slew of AI- driven selected variables that drive sales lifts leading to 15x to 19x ROAS. These state-of-the-art products can stymie old and tired media models. This is because, in some retailer attribution models, high-impact display is treated
with the same modeling considerations as boring, small, and entirely missable standard display ads. Of course, this is plain wrong, yields misleading results, and is hurtful to retailer aspirations.
This note attempts to better explain
what drives retail store visits, and perhaps a simpler and more effective means of being largely right in motivating people to make a trip to the local grocer, department, or specialty store. Let’s review first the slew of issues in attribution when using digital channels to encourage physical store visits: 1. Last Touch importance. It’s hard
to believe that some modelers still give credence to this model, dismissing or trivializing all prior upper/mid funnel activity that influenced the final touchpoint. Last touchpoints are the results of many initiatives to stimulate desire and exploration. Perhaps useful for very shorter-term, one-time campaigns and products, at best. One-time inventory liquidation might be a good use. Sadly, last touch attribution is the default positioning for most tools, even Google Analytics. It is just
preposterous to consider all marketing spend can be attributed to the last link in a strategic chain. 2. First Touch models which believe that simple PPC ads suddenly drive consumer desire! First touchpoints may be relevant for driving to a specific supplier, but desire was created long before. This model completely ignores the effects of other consumer interactions after the initial touchpoint. 3. Multi-Touch, with all its various alternatives (linear, non-direct, customized, time decay, U-shaped)1 modeling has the appealing promise of optimizing media to drive consumers down the purchase funnel. Multi-Touch attribution (MTA) is directionally much better in that at least this modeling attempts to understand that many factors drive behavior, and that multichannel marketing is a proven technique. Still, in
the attempt to be precisely wrong, multi-touch models are assigned percentage effectiveness in many cases. Those percentages are highly critical variables and are certainly precise, but almost universally are inaccurate. For example, marketers will develop percentages for video and display, attributing more sales to a video campaign. But what happens when hybrid ad units are used, or dynamic creative is installed, or if
both display and video are intertwined strategically? MTA solutions are limited to marketing channels where direct response can be tracked via touch points and consumer identifiers. In addition, MTA solutions are quickly becoming impossible to implement with the degradation of current consumer identification solutions. Rules based MTA solutions use qualitative judgment and largely touchpoints to determine which channel receives
credit, ignoring the full impact of media exposure. Because of the requirements to deploy MTA, media providers often focus on what works to drive strong MTA results, chasing bottom of the funnel touches, reach and/or high frequency, which counterintuitively might not be what is optimal to drive sales. MTA is thus a flawed methodology:
● Association of a sale to a single channel ignores the full value of media in favor of
operational convenience. The 99% of exposures that don’t generate touchpoints are significantly undervalued or not valued at all.
● Due to different delivery frequencies, MTA often obscures the value of high impact media formats such as video and rich media.
● Many MTA solutions are not incremental and thus inflate the performance of media by attributing sales that would have happened without media to various marketing efforts.
The final nail in the MTA coffin is
the loss of consumer ID solutions as the global privacy movement gains steam. MTA solutions will not be able to track funnel behavior and have large gaps in data collection. Lost signals include, for example:
● Publisher 1st party opt-in requirements
● App Transparency Tracking (ATT) – Apple’s app tracking initiative
● Cookie deprecation (Google’s back-and-forth threats to shut down cookies on Chrome)
● Closed
social platforms
For digital marketers, the issue of media effectiveness using newer methods is not just difficult, but getting harder as ID deprecation further scrambles the picture.
INTRODUCING “INCREMENTAL RETURN ON AD SALES, OR iROAS”
It is time for a bit of “back to the future”, and shift from models that try to capture everything happening all at once, andinstead do the hard work of determining
the incremental sales driven by discrete marketing endeavors. We call this the “iROAS” model. Determining incremental sales relies on the hard work of TEST and CONTROL. This method may not appeal as something new and sexy; it is as old as the hills. Because each market has some set of unique aspects around competition, income, weather, time of day, and many more exogenous variables, there are no complex yet simultaneously simple-minded holistic models that can predict local retail campaign
outcomes. The notion of “iROAS” is to do the painstaking work of holding all media constant market by market, then creating test and control vehicles to isolate the single change in media that can explain sales, traffic or other variable changes.
A NEW APPROACH TO MEASUREMENT
At Undertone, we work closely with Incrementlogy, Inc. to create improved approaches to using media to drive
incremental
sales. The tents of Incrementology’s approach are:
● Use causation to isolate the full value of media exposure, rather than just touchpoints.
● Deploy machine learning to quickly measure each media channel and calibrate the brand’s entire media portfolio to achieve their goals and implement through an intuitive platform empowers brands to test, measure, and action often to ensure performance.
● Do not depend on consumer identification to measure media value, rather using
it for granular insights if/when it is available.
USE POWERFUL MACHINE LEARNING TO MODEL AND SIMULATE OUTCOMES
● Both Channel Measurement & Portfolio Calibration – Use machine learning to quickly measure the full value of individual media channels, as well as providing calibration recommendations for media weight across a brand’s media portfolio.
● Speed to Market – Machine learning replaces the expensive and lengthy integration of solutions such as MTA
and media mix modeling (MMM).
● Comparable Metrics Across Channels – Different channels have different performance indicators. Search, display, video and social all have different KPIs. Causal measurement provides the brand with comparable metrics across channels.
● Measurement of Closed Channels – While closed social channels often prevent the identification of consumers to outside media providers, most allow for the use of geography to test for causality. This is something MTA solutions
simply cannot provide.
FIND CAUSALITY
● Use machine learning to quickly identify store-level markets (or other geography) with similar sales to identify both test and control markets.
● Causal inference models estimate expected sales in the test markets before the media is launched.
● After media campaigns launch sales in the test and control markets are used to simulate what sales in the test
markets would have been without marketing.
● This method does not require consumer level tracking or complex media integration.
CALIBRATE CHANNELS
● Employ machine learning to determine the best calibration or mix of media channels to drive incremental sales.
● Channel calibration can be fine-tuned with inputs from Incrementology’s Incremental Sales Analysis and/or other individual campaign or channel measurement results.
● Using advanced regression techniques and probability
distribution methods both the optimal weight and allocation of media channels are determined.
● These same models also provide insight on the effects of each media format across the purchase funnel.
Media measurement and attribution is a critical tool for retailers, yet deployed in ways that drive the wrong conclusions. It is possible to be both directionally accurate and precise when shifting from naive media
measurement effectiveness models to models that focus on incremental sales, executed by identifying causality with advanced machine learning and regression models. The hard work this entails may not sound exciting, but it is what must be done.
ABOUT THE AUTHORS
Daniel Aks is the President of Undertone, A Perion Company, leveraging his broad operating experience in C-level roles for the
information, education, & consumer media industries. For the two years before joining Undertone, Daniel was the CEO of Antenna International, where he led their successful turnaround by introducing new products, lowering costs, & building an innovative culture. He also served as COO of the Educational Records Bureau for the prior three years, where he increased revenue by 20%, introduced new assessment products, & reduced costs. Previously, Daniel served as COO/CoS of McGraw-Hill
Education where he led its reorganization & developed formative testing & data-driven instruction products. He also served as COO for PRIMEDIA Consumer Magazines & as President of its Internet Business, where he launched & led the pioneering digital business.
Brian Pozesky is the Co-Founder and President of Incrementology. He us an incremental measurement pioneer with 20+ years’ experience
building and scaling start-ups. Builder of data science, operations, product and programmatic media groups. Developer and designer of business intelligence tools and large-scale data systems. Holder of patented creative optimization and testing algorithms.
Paul H. Van Wert is the Co-Founder and is the leader of Incrementology’s analytics and Products Marketing capabilities. He is a measurement expert and
performance advertising innovator. Experienced in developing retail media networks, leading agile development teams and managing analytics organizations. Product designer at multiple high-growth start-ups using cutting-edge data & machine learning technologies to deliver strategic insights and accurate measurement of marketing investments.
|
All the news you need today, in a format that isn't TL:DR, summarized for the busy executive.
Kroger ditches the printed path and embraces the digital revolution, waving goodbye to circulars and hello to a bold new approach. With rising costs and distribution challenges, the grocery giant opts for a digital-first strategy, proving that even traditional industries can adapt to the changing tides
of marketing. It's a cart full of savings and a swipe away from success as Kroger sets a new trend for retailers everywhere.
Performance marketing may provide short-term wins, but it's time to break down the barriers that hinder long-term growth. First, integrate media and creative teams to unify strategies and improve performance. Second, look beyond superficial metrics and focus on true business goals by utilizing advanced measurement
tactics. Finally, understand the complex consumer journey and create authentic content that moves them closer to becoming brand advocates. It's time to recalibrate and prioritize the consumer experience for lasting success.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has announced updated Endorsement Guides to combat deceptive reviews and endorsements in advertising. The revised guides provide guidance to businesses to ensure truthful
advertising practices. The updates address emerging market trends and include new principles on distorting consumer reviews, addressing incentivized and fake negative reviews, clarifying disclosure requirements, and highlighting the liability of advertisers, endorsers, and intermediaries. The FTC has also issued an updated FAQ document providing specific guidance for influencers on disclosing material connections. The revised guides aim to promote fair and transparent advertising practices and
protect consumers.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has announced updated Endorsement Guides to combat deceptive reviews and endorsements in advertising. The revised guides provide guidance to businesses to ensure truthful advertising practices. The updates address emerging market trends and include new principles on distorting consumer reviews, addressing incentivized
and fake negative reviews, clarifying disclosure requirements, and highlighting the liability of advertisers, endorsers, and intermediaries. The FTC has also issued an updated FAQ document providing specific guidance for influencers on disclosing material connections. The revised guides aim to promote fair and transparent advertising practices and protect consumers.
Dr. Augustine
Fou, an expert in ad fraud, reflects on the long history of scams and fraudulent practices in the digital advertising industry. He discusses how techniques like keyword stuffing and click fraud have evolved over the years, with fraudsters now utilizing chat bots and text-based AI platforms to automate and scale their fraudulent activities. Dr. Fou highlights the prevalence of fake websites and bought traffic, emphasizing that legacy fraud verification vendors often fail to detect these
fraudulent activities. He provides examples of large-scale fraud operations and the challenges faced in prosecuting these cases, including instances where major fraud went undetected by industry players. Dr. Fou advises advertisers to be proactive in preventing their money from flowing to fraudsters by using blocklists and inclusion lists, being selective about the sites and apps they work with, and implementing analytics to monitor campaign performance. He offers FouAnalytics as a tool for
advertisers to detect and block fraudulent sites and apps.
According to the information provided, Warner Bros Discovery (WBD) is reportedly planning to add live CNN feeds to its streaming platform Max, but only outside the United States. The feed available within the US will likely be limited to non-live segments of popular domestic CNN shows. The decision to restrict the live CNN feed to international markets may seem puzzling to
external observers, as it would provide an additional unique selling point for the streaming app. However, for those familiar with the industry, this move is not surprising. WBD is constrained in the US due to its reliance on the substantial carriage fees it receives from MVPDs (Multichannel Video Programming Distributors). The exact amount of these fees is known only to CNN's finance team but is presumed to be a significant sum. Therefore, WBD intends to continue maximizing these carriage fees
for as long as possible, which may explain the limited availability of CNN on their streaming platform. It is also mentioned that WBD has discontinued CNN+, a separate streaming service.
IBM has revamped its partner ecosystem, creating a special tier called the "blue partners" that includes industry giants
like Adobe, AWS, Cisco, Microsoft, Salesforce, Samsung, and SAP. With over $1 trillion in global technology purchases and 100 million developers combined, these partnerships bring together the best of the best in AI and hybrid cloud solutions. It's a case of 1+1=3, where IBM's expertise and their partners' tech capabilities merge to create powerful and holistic offerings, all while IBM Consulting adds the final touch of deployment finesse. It's like assembling a dream team, except this
one actually delivers results. Google, the multitasking handyman of the tech world, has introduced new features for Search and Performance Max campaigns, offering more control over ad placements and brand restrictions. With the ability to target specific brand traffic and exclude certain brands,
advertisers can expect improved ad performance and higher quality traffic. Additionally, Google has launched Privacy Sandbox Demos on GitHub, allowing users to test its privacy-focused APIs, including features like remarketing and single-touch conversion attribution. However, amidst these updates, a friendly reminder is given that Buy on Google for Search and Shopping will soon end in the US, shifting its focus solely to Buy on Google for YouTube. So, don't forget to update your to-do list and
fulfill any pending orders accordingly.
According to a study conducted by SimpleTexting, consumers tend to be more responsive to text messages from brands compared to emails. The study revealed that a higher percentage of shoppers reply to texts within minutes, while emails have lower response rates. However, it's important to note that emails serve a different marketing
purpose and may not always require an immediate response. The study also highlighted that younger generations tend to check their text messages more frequently than other activities, placing email lower on the list. On the business side, more owners have increased their SMS budgets and integrated text marketing with other channels, reporting higher conversion rates. Overall, the study suggests that combining different marketing channels yields better results, and text messaging is particularly
valued for customer service, reminders, and engagement.
|
You're looking for an edge in your online marketing.
Interest: ADOTAT.com is the answer. Our library of resources has been compiled by some
of the world's top internet marketing experts, and it's constantly updated with new information, case studies, and strategies.
We want to help you succeed online - that's why we offer this information for free. It's our way of giving back to the community and helping people achieve their business goals.
Sign up now and gain access to our entire library of resources!
Want to advertise? Contact pesach@lattin.us |
|
|
The most POWERFUL name in TCPA
Privacy CIPA AI class action defense and counseling |
INSIDE THE GOOGLE VIDEO AD SCAM
It’s bad. It’s actually worse than everyone was saying. Google may owe advertisers billions of dollars
and face huge lawsuits after scamming advertisers. For years, many people, including myself, have questioned the ecosystem of online advertising, particularly Google’s enormous advertising growth that seems to be backed by junk and scam sites. Now, new research reveals that Google has violated its promised standards when placing video ads on other websites, raising serious concerns about the transparency and integrity of the tech giant’s online ad business. READ THE FULL EXCITING STORY
THE FUTURE OF PROGRAMMATIC: MATT BARASH DEFENDS THE SSP.
In an exclusive interview with VideoWeek, Matt Barash, Vice President at IndexExchange, provides valuable insights into the ever-evolving programmatic advertising landscape. With over 20 years of experience, IndexExchange has transformed from an ad network into a formidable exchange model, helping publishers monetize their assets. Barash highlights the seismic shifts witnessed in the industry, emphasizing the rise
of quality and video as paramount factors driving change.
READ THE INTERVIEW
CRITEO’S COMPLIANCE WOES: REGULATORS SHOW THEY MEAN BUSINESS In a stunning turn of events, adtech firm Criteo has found itself in hot water with regulators, facing a hefty penalty of 40 million euros (U.S. $44 million) for multiple alleged violations of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). The French data protection authority, CNIL, recently announced the fine, which sent shockwaves through the industry and left Criteo employees feeling like their yacht had suddenly transformed into a funeral barge, with no
explanation for this colossal punishment.
READ MORE NOW
UNMASKING THE SCAM: MADE-FOR-ADVERTISING SITES EXPOSEDIn a world dominated by programmatic
advertising, the allure of maximizing ad impressions and clicks can lead advertisers down a treacherous path. Enter the realm of Made-for-Advertising (MFA) websites – a breeding ground for spam, click-bait, and low-quality content. These sites have been quietly siphoning billions of dollars from unsuspecting advertisers, while tarnishing their brands in the process. A recent study by the Association of National Advertisers (ANA) reveals the alarming extent of the MFA problem, urging advertisers
to take immediate action.
READ MORE NOW
SUPPLY-PATH OPTIMIZATION: UNRAVELING THE COMPLEXITY OF PROGRAMMATIC AD BUYING At its core, SPO is about buyers making deliberate choices to identify the most efficient connections and transact with sellers. The goal is to eliminate inefficient and expensive paths to supply, ensuring that advertisers get the most value for their investment. However, the term “SPO” has been thrown around by nearly every constituent in the supply chain, creating unnecessary complexity and confusion. It’s time to cut through the noise and focus on the core opportunity
at hand.
READ MORE NOW!
THE FUTURE OF TV ADVERTISING: CTV’S DOMINANCE AND INNOVATION The world of television advertising has undergone a significant transformation with the rise of Connected TV (CTV) and the convergence of digital and linear platforms. To explore the exciting innovations and trends in this space, industry experts Jenn Chen from Connatix, James Chanter from Finecast, and Ilana Wollin from Xandr took the stage at the recent
Captivate conference. We now delve into their insightful conversation to gain a deeper understanding of the advancements and challenges within the CTV landscape.
READ MORE
NOW!
DAVE MORGAN, CEO OF SIMULMEDIA, VISITS UKRAINE: A VIBRANT ADTECH HUB AMIDST TURMOIL Ukraine, a country known for its rich adtech ecosystem, has continued to thrive despite ongoing conflicts and geopolitical challenges. Recently, Dave Morgan, the visionary CEO of Simulmedia, embarked on a journey to Ukraine, where he experienced firsthand the resilience, innovation, and unwavering spirit of the Ukrainian people. In this unique article, we delve into Morgan’s visit, exploring the thriving adtech industry
in Ukraine and the incredible opportunities it presents.
READ MORE NOW!
CTV’S CAPTAIN FANTASTIC: MIKE SEIMAN AND THE RISE OF PERFORMANCE-DRIVEN TV
As the CEO and Chairman of Digital Remedy,
he's been juggling eyeballs, clicks, and ROI like a seasoned pro. From direct response ad networks to media buying nirvana, Seiman's journey has been a wild ride filled with lessons, laughter, and a healthy dose of innovation. With his sights set on conquering CTV and OTT, he's rewriting the rules and turning campaigns into dazzling performances. So, grab your popcorn and get ready for a show like no other, because with Seiman at the helm, digital advertising just got a whole lot wittier and a
whole lot more profitable. READ ENTIRE STORY |
|
